What do I do When They Don’t Keep Their Agreements?

I posted a blog a couple days ago on making clear agreements.  I laid out the following 3 elements for an agreement:

1.  When we are in a meeting with several people (or even 2), ask specifically “who will do this?” and wait for a response.  If no response, then state clearly, “No one has agreed to do this.”

2.  If someone says they will do what needs to be done, ask for the specifics of what they are promising to do.

3.  Be sure they specify BY WHEN the promise will be fulfilled.


Here is a Q&A I had with a reader after she saw my blog:

Q:  Do you have suggestions for how to move forward when all 3 steps are taken, but the deadline is ignored?

A:  I do, actually.  I think this represents the gap between this blog and my accountability blogs (available on this site).  I recommend there be a consequence.  It does not need to be punitive in nature.  When an organization is shifting from a culture of not making clear agreements and/or not keeping agreements (as yours may be) to a culture of making clear agreements and keeping the agreements, there always is a gap because people think they can “get away” without keeping agreements.  This is not bad or wrong, just how they have learned to be.  Humans tend to test whether there are consequences to breaking agreements (starting at a very young age :).

My coaching to management and employees in organizations going through this:  if you have clear agreements and the deadline comes and goes, you go to that person and you kindly, neutrally, without energy ask “what happened?”  “Did you believe we had an agreement?”  “What got in the way of you keeping this agreement?”  And listen closely to the answers – you will learn valuable information.  Then: “What needs to happen next time so you keep this agreement?”  It is very important you not come across as judgmental or angry – just curious.

Very often, people start to change when they realize someone is going to call them out.  If they don’t, this is the next level which requires a stricter consequence.  But I wouldn’t go there until you have really tried this one out.

Questions?  Thoughts?  Does this help?

Q:  It does help, thank you. My initial reaction is one of “how dare they? Is the agreement we made not valid in their eyes?” I need to step away and see that because this has been the norm for so long, and there have been no consequences to inaction, that it’s nothing personal, has nothing to do with me. I can be neutral (which is my preferred method anyhow) and simply ask the question.

I appreciate your response. Now I have a nice neutral email to write.

A:  Excellent awareness.  It is common to feel this is somehow about you – their not keeping their agreements.  It is far easier when you don’t take it personally.  Have fun – and let me know what happens.

About the Author

Cami McLaren

Cami McLaren

is the owner of McLaren Coaching. She has been coaching professionals and leaders since early 2008. She runs Transformative Coaching Essentials, a coach training program that produces first rate Professional Coaches and "Coach-Style Leaders." She coaches individually and works with organizations to improve communication, time management, productivity and ultimately bring greater results.

Get Our Newsletter
Recent Posts
Be committed, but not attached

Be committed, but not attached

A long time ago, I heard this quote that really messed with my brain. Though I cannot find the source of this exact quote, there are many similar Buddhist tenets. It has really helped me get what I want in my life, though! “Be committed,...

Read More
Tracie Hewitt

Coach Highlight – Tracie Hewitt

CM: Why did you enter TCE? And/or, what did you want to get out of it? TH: I took the training because as a licensed educational psychologist (LEP), I found myself “coaching” parents around issues with their children, including learning disabilities, autism, ADHD, depression and...

Read More

Coach Highlight – Megan Moore

CM: Why did you enter TCE? And/or, what did you want to get out of it? MM: I enrolled in TCE to deepen my communication and leadership skills. At the time, I was one year into running my solo law practice and in my eleventh...

Read More
Managers and Their Moods: What You Might Not Know

Managers and Their Moods: What You Might Not Know

“I have come to the frightening conclusion that I am the decisive element. It is my personal approach that creates the climate. It is my daily mood that makes the weather….In all situations, it is my response that decides whether a crisis is escalated or...

Read More

Share this Post